Grady Hendrix is one of my favorite authors, and with Spooky Season coming up, what better time to start talking about some spooky books than now (not that I’ve ever needed an excuse)?
As a disclaimer, this list does not include Hendrix’s self-published novellas, his early short story collection, or his nonfiction works, as these are not as widely accessible and many exist in categories outside the genre of horror. Below, I’ve ranked all seven of Hendrix’s mainstream-published horror novels, as well as the two short stories he’s published in the last few years as part of Amazon’s Creature Feature and The Shivers collections, which feature short horror stories by top authors in the genre like Stephen Graham Jones (The Only Good Indians, I Was a Teenage Slasher, The Buffalo Hunter Hunter) and Joe Hill (20th Century Ghosts, NOS4A2, The Fireman).
9. We Sold Our Souls
Overall Goodreads Rating: 3.71/5 stars
My Goodreads Rating: 2/5 stars
One-sentence summary: Kris, a former heavy metal guitarist, fights back against a former bandmate who once betrayed her and who is now in league with dark supernatural forces.
Relevant subgenres and tropes: Supernatural/paranormal horror, cult horror, vague slasher vibes
The premise was interesting, and it had a lot of potential, but it felt oddly lackluster and disappointing for what it was. The one thing he did successfully in this book is the thing that makes so many of his other books so great: the way he writes friendships between women. There just wasn’t enough of it for me to care about this book, like, at all. I thought the section where Kris and Melanie crossed paths was amazing, but I almost wish that they'd been friends the whole book, or that we'd at least gotten a more satisfactory ending for the two of them. As it was, this book felt underdeveloped, and the relationships between Kris and her bandmates (all men) just felt kind of so-so, while every woman who wasn't Kris or Melanie felt like an extra in a movie who had no personality.
8. How to Sell a Haunted House
Overall Goodreads rating: 3.65/5 stars
My Goodreads rating: 3/5
One-sentence summary: Following the sudden death of her parents, a single middle-aged mother must travel back to her hometown to help settle her parents’ affairs and clean out the house while dealing with her man-child brother (and also some creepy dolls, puppets, and taxidermized woodland creatures).
Relevant subgenres and tropes: Supernatural/paranormal horror, haunted/possessed dolls
This one wasn’t technically bad. I didn’t dislike it. I just got a bit bored with it by the end because there was a mystery, and it didn’t seem like anything was being done “on-screen” to solve that mystery. The dolls and puppets were pretty creepy and weird, and at points a bit upsetting. The squirrels were honestly kind of hilarious. While this one wasn’t my favorite, I’d still recommend it as a fair example of what Hendrix’s work is like—if you’re patient enough to get past some of the boring bits.
7. Horrorstör
Overall Goodreads rating: 3.65/5 stars
My Goodreads rating: 3/5 stars
One-sentence summary: A woman working at an Ikea-knockoff store is voluntold to work overnight while the store is closed to help solve the mystery of whether or not someone has been sneaking into the store at night—but the truth is way weirder.
Relevant subgenres and tropes: Supernatural/paranormal horror
I think the most fun part of this book is that the physical copy is laid out like an Ikea catalog. There are diagrams and store maps in the front matter, and throughout, there are pictures of the furniture described in the book that get more and more unhinged as the story progresses.
Other than that, much like the previous book, this book was just kind of boring. And much like the previous two books, it was lacking in the female friendship department. I wish there’d been more of that, and some more intrigue and more of an explanation of whatever the deal with the restless spirits was.
I did appreciate the retail worker representation, and the night-shift worker representation in this one. A lot of this weirdly felt the same as working nights at Walmart when I was in grad school during the pandemic.
6. My Best Friend’s Exorcism
Overall Goodreads rating: 3.93/5 stars
My Goodreads rating: 4/5 stars
One-sentence summary: A group of girls spend the weekend at a friend’s parents’ lakehouse doing teenager things like swimming in the lake, going for walks outside, and playing with a ouija board; over the next few weeks, one of the girls goes through a rapid decline, and her friend determines she must be possessed by a demon.
Relevant subgenres and tropes: Supernatural/paranormal horror, demonic possession, possession as a metaphor for sexual trauma, period piece (1980s)
This was the second book I read by Hendrix, and I didn’t love it as much as the first one I read, but by this point, I knew what I loved most about his books: the way he writes women’s friendships. For a man, he does this tastefully and with incredible authenticity, which makes me feel like he must have grown up in a predominantly female household, or he was the only boy in his friend group when he was in school.
Regardless, I loved this book right up until the actual exorcism scene, which I thought was really cheesy and embarrassing, though I did understand what he was going for. Up until that point, I loved the various character interactions, and I loved the main character’s commitment to her friend and finding out what was wrong and how hard she fought to help her. There were cringey moments—of course there were! That’s Hendrix’s whole thing—but nothing felt out of place or made me actually roll my eyes until the exorcism happened.
5. The Final Girl Support Group
Overall Goodreads rating: 3.51/5 stars
My Goodreads rating: 4/5 stars (probably closer to 4.5 if I’m being fair, but I don’t like slashers)
One-sentence summary: A member of a support group for real-life “final girls” (the survivors of slasher attacks) realizes someone is killing off the women from her support group and now must battle her own intense PTSD and social awkwardness, as well as the killer, to try to stop him before he kills anyone else.
Relevant subgenres and tropes: Slashers, references to supernatural/paranormal horror and Lovecraftian/Eldritch horror
I initially rated this one 3/5 stars when I first read it, but after reading We Sold Our Souls and really disliking that one, I realized Final Girl Support Group actually wasn’t that bad. In fact, all the action, humor, drama, and gore were there, and there was an excellent mystery plot that was full of twists and turns. I just really don't like slasher movies, so I don’t feel like I probably got as much out of this one as someone who does like those kinds of movies might have. If you love slasher films, this might be an excellent book for you!
4. “Ankle Snatcher” (part of Amazon’s Creature Feature collection)
Overall Goodreads rating: 3.70/5 stars
My Goodreads rating: 4/5 stars
One-sentence summary: Ever since his father suffered a mental break and murdered his mother, Marcus has feared the dark and romantic intimacy; one night, a date sleeps over at his apartment—and makes the mistake of turning off the light.
Relevant subgenres and tropes: Psychological horror, supernatural/paranormal horror, generational trauma
This is Grady Hendrix’s only mainstream-published work told from the perspective of a man, which I find fascinating. He’s very good at telling women’s stories, but I never considered until I read this that he never really writes about men’s thoughts and experiences, so it was interesting to see this shift in perspective.
While this story and The Final Girl Support Group both get four stars, I definitely like this one more because I tend to prefer supernatural or paranormal horror over horror stories featuring humans killing other humans, and I think that’s what Hendrix does best anyway.
Also, shout-out to the Discovery Channel, which was basically a supporting character.
3. The Southern Book Club’s Guide to Slaying Vampires
Overall Goodreads rating: 3.79/5 stars
My Goodreads rating: 5/5 stars
One-sentence summary: A bored stay-at-home mom from Charleston, South Carolina, helps the new guy who moved in down the street get settled in after finding out he’s the nephew of the old woman with dementia who attacked her while she was taking out the trash, only to find out later that he’s a vampire who wants to take over the whole community.
Relevant subgenres and tropes: Vampires, monsters, supernatural/paranormal horror, vampirism as a metaphor for sexual violence
This was the first book by Hendrix I read, and even after reading all the rest, it’s still one of my favorites. This one really is Hendrix at his best, and this is probably the book I’d recommend first if someone asked me what a good book by him is, or for a good modern twist on the vampire novel. There are a lot of fun callbacks to other vampire books, films, and TV series, and lots of strong female characters.
2. “The Blanks” (part of Amazon’s The Shivers Collection)
Overall Goodreads rating: 3.95/5 stars
My Goodreads rating: 5/5 stars
One-sentence summary: Wealthy families staying on Jekyll Island live in relative peace and harmony amid the idyllic landscape—there’s just one rule: don’t look at the monsters that call the island home.
Relevant subgenres and tropes: Supernatural/paranormal horror, paranoia
This short story came out earlier this year, and I was really excited about it because I got to read it early, before it was published. Hendrix did not disappoint.
While many of his earlier works have felt very kooky and campy and silly, this felt like a very serious, almost Stephen-King-esque horror story. There was no comedy to break up any of the tension. Hendrix told the story straight, and for the first third or so, it read like a simple summer story about a family on vacation. Then came the first sighting of “The Blanks,” monsters native to the island that are sort of hard to describe. But what they look like doesn’t matter so much as what they do, which the main character doesn’t exactly tell us at first, which adds to the suspense.
The main character lets her son go ahead of her to the beach to meet his friends, and later, she learns that he saw a Blank attack another person. She asks him if he looked at it, and he swears he didn’t. If he did, it was only for a moment.
But only a moment is enough.
She becomes paranoid and locks her family up in their house, locking and barring the doors, shuttering and boarding up the windows, convinced that because the Blanks saw her son, they will come back for him.
This story was only 35 pages, but it was terrifying. I think he could have stretched it out into a whole novel if he wanted, but I respect the decision to keep it condensed into a short story because this is one of the best things he’s written, and one of the best short horror stories I’ve ever read.
1. Witchcraft for Wayward Girls
Overall Goodreads rating: 3.96/5 stars
My Goodreads rating: 5/5 stars (I’d give it more if I could)
One-sentence summary: An unwed pregnant teen is sent to a home St. Augustine, Florida, against her will by her parents to have her baby and then give it up for adoption; along the way, she befriends the other girls in the house and together they learn the true meaning of friendship, love, and family, and that being a woman means supporting other women.
Relevant subgenres and tropes: Witches and witchcraft, supernatural/paranormal horror, period piece (1970s), fantasy
I struggle to agree with the classification of this as a horror novel. It wasn’t really scary to me (except for the graphic description of the protagonist giving birth, and the sense of discomfort and anxiety I felt throughout every time one of the girls was scared or hurt or sick), but it was an amazing book with some really interesting fantasy elements. I was impressed for a number of reasons, but mostly because this was a book written by a middle-aged man about a bunch of pregnant teenage girls. There was a lot that could have gone wrong simply because he was writing about an experience he has never had and never has to worry about, but in reality, there were only one or two things that made me go, “I… don’t think that’s how that works.” Hendrix did his homework, and he listened to enough stories from people who had been pregnant and given birth before to get those elements as close to accurate as they possibly could have been. Between this and “The Blanks,” I think Grady Hendrix is really coming into his own as a “serious” author.
Copies of many of these works can be found across the three campus libraries.